The University of Southern California has faced criticism from a leading Muslim group after canceling a planned commencement speech by its valedictorian, Asna Tabassum. The university cited security concerns due to tensions over the ongoing conflict in the Middle East. Tabassum expressed shock and disappointment at the decision, accusing the university of giving in to hate meant to silence her voice. USC Provost Andrew Guzman said that discussions surrounding the valedictorian choice had taken an alarming turn in recent days, with social media and the conflict in the Middle East exacerbating the situation and creating security risks.
At least two pro-Israel and Jewish groups complained to USC about Tabassum’s selection as valedictorian, pointing to her social media activity. Tabassum’s Instagram account linked to a slideshow advocating for the abolition of the state of Israel and the establishment of a Palestinian state. This was deemed by Trojans for Israel as antisemitic bigotry. Tabassum clarified that she added the link five years ago and was not the author. She emphasized her identity as a first-generation South Asian-American Muslim and highlighted her academic background in biomedical engineering and resistance to genocide.
Tabassum expressed her desire to inspire her classmates with a message of hope through her commencement speech, hoping to combat the spread of fear-fueled hate. She criticized USC for canceling her speech, stating that the university’s decision played into fear and rewarded hatred. Tabassum was selected as valedictorian by a committee based on her academic achievements, and social media presence was not a factor in the decision-making process. USC denied claims made by Tabassum that the university refused to provide increased security measures for her speech, stating that such claims were inaccurate.
The conflict in the Middle East has sparked strong emotions on college campuses, leading to allegations of antisemitism and Islamophobia. USC Provost Guzman emphasized that the decision to cancel Tabassum’s speech was based on campus security and safety concerns, rather than freedom of speech issues. He mentioned instances of harassment and violence on other campuses and asserted that tradition must give way to safety. The Council on American-Islamic Relations criticized USC’s decision, labeling it as cowardly and accusing the university of hiding behind security concerns as a guise for Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian racism. The organization defended Tabassum and other college students who speak up for human rights and Palestinian humanity.
In the midst of escalating tensions and misinformation, it is essential for universities to uphold principles of diversity, inclusion, and freedom of expression. The cancellation of Asna Tabassum’s commencement speech at USC raises questions about the balance between security concerns and the preservation of academic freedom. Initiating dialogue, promoting understanding, and fostering a respectful environment for diverse perspectives are critical in navigating complex issues such as the Middle East conflict. It is crucial for institutions to address concerns of discrimination, bigotry, and hate speech while upholding values of tolerance, respect, and peaceful coexistence. By reevaluating policies and procedures, universities can promote a culture of inclusivity and mutual respect among students of various backgrounds and beliefs.
