CNET editors select products and services based on editorial merit, and may receive a commission when you buy through their links. When testing mattresses, they assess factors like firmness, feel, and performance to determine the best hypoallergenic options. This includes verifying that all materials are allergy-safe and examining how each layer contributes to the bed’s hypoallergenic qualities. Factors such as firmness, feel, durability, body type accommodation, sleeping position support, motion isolation, edge support, and temperature control are all considered in the testing process.
To evaluate firmness, CNET testers lie on each mattress and simulate sleeping in various positions, such as stomach, back, side, and combination. By drawing on their experience testing nearly 300 mattresses, they analyze the construction and determine how soft or hard a bed feels compared to others. The feel of a mattress is assessed through hands-on interaction, observing how the materials behave – whether light and bouncy like latex foam or slow and dense like memory foam. Durability is estimated by examining construction, with steel coil beds generally being more durable than all-foam mattresses.
Body type accommodation is an important consideration, as different mattresses suit different individuals based on weight and sleeping habits. Hybrid mattresses with steel coils are usually more supportive and longer-lasting, especially for heavier individuals or couples. Testing includes trying out different sleeping positions, such as side, back, stomach, and combination, to determine how well a mattress supports each one. Motion isolation is also assessed, with testers jumping and bouncing to see how much movement can be felt throughout the bed, as well as conducting tests with a cup of water to check for disturbance.
Edge support is evaluated by analyzing a mattress’s materials and physically lying on each edge to assess how sturdy it feels. Temperature control testing involves using hot sleepers to gauge how cool a mattress sleeps, as well as examining its construction for any special technology designed to enhance cooling. By combining these tests, CNET aims to provide comprehensive reviews and recommendations for hypoallergenic mattresses that address a range of factors important to consumers. Their established process ensures that customers can make informed decisions when choosing a mattress that suits their needs and preferences.