“The Tearsmith,” directed by Alessandro Genovesi and adapted from Fabbricante di lacrime by Erin Doom, follows the story of Nica and Rigel, who were raised in a brutal orphanage filled with fairy tale imagery. As they navigate their complicated relationship and traumatic pasts, they are adopted by a couple as teenagers. The film explores themes of love, trauma, and the search for a fairy tale ending, with a twist on traditional narratives.
Nica, who was sent to Sunnycreek Home after her parents’ death, finds solace in her friendship with Adeline but struggles under the cruelty of headmistress Margaret. After being adopted by a couple who recently lost their son, Nica is reunited with Rigel, the boy Margaret favored. As they adjust to their new family dynamic, they also face the challenges of high school and their budding romance, all while confronting their shared past at the orphanage.
Amidst longing looks and emotional turmoil, Nica and Rigel grapple with their traumas and feelings for each other. While Nica embraces her new family, Rigel struggles to admit his growing attachment to her. When Adeline reveals plans to pursue charges against Margaret for abuse, Nica is inspired to come forward and confront her own scars. The film delves into themes of love, brokenness, and the struggle to find healing after trauma.
The forbidden romance between Nica and Rigel draws comparisons to the Twilight saga, with its smoldering tension and emotional depth. Caterina Ferioli delivers a strong performance as Nica, embodying a sense of confidence and vulnerability. Supporting performances from Nicky Passarella and Sveva Romana Candelletta add depth to the story, although some aspects of their characters’ arcs are left unresolved.
While the chemistry between Nica and Rigel is palpable, the film’s setting and various elements may distract from the central romance. The reliance on US aesthetics and unclear location create a disconnect from the story, affecting the immersion in the characters’ journey. The film touches on complex themes of love, trauma, and family dynamics, but some aspects may not fully align with the fairy tale-inspired narrative.
Overall, “The Tearsmith” offers moments of genuine chemistry and emotional depth between its characters. The slow burn romance and exploration of trauma add layers to the story, but some elements may not fully resonate with all audiences. Despite its compelling themes and performances, the film’s execution may leave some viewers wanting more coherence in the narrative.
