Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, recently faced criticism after an op-ed he wrote over three decades ago resurfaced, in which he expressed pro-Israel views and disparaged the Palestinian people. Despite the controversial comments made in his youth, Shapiro’s spokesman emphasized that the governor has since built close relationships with various leaders of Muslim-American, Arab-American, Palestinian Christian, and Jewish communities in Pennsylvania. He explained that Shapiro’s views have evolved over the years through his experiences and interactions, leading to his current belief in a two-state solution for peace in the Middle East.
The old essay, originally published in the student newspaper of the University of Rochester where Shapiro graduated in 1995, highlighted his belief that Palestinians lacked the ability to peacefully coexist and establish a successful homeland. These comments have resurfaced as Shapiro is being considered for a potential vice-presidential nomination. The governor’s unwavering support for Israel, despite the strong pro-Palestinian views within parts of the Democratic Party, has led to criticism and pressure from opponents, who have launched campaigns against his candidacy. However, some Jewish members of Congress have defended Shapiro, stating that assumptions that Jewish politicians cannot be objective on Israel are unfair and unfounded.
In response to the resurfacing of the op-ed, Shapiro’s spokesman pushed back on the idea that this single article from his youth reflects the governor’s current beliefs. The spokesman reiterated Shapiro’s stance on supporting a two-state solution for Israelis and Palestinians to live peacefully together, emphasizing the need for both sides to work towards lasting peace. Despite facing scrutiny, Shapiro has worked hard to bring people together, listen to communities, and ensure safety and inclusion for all Pennsylvanians. He has stressed the importance of allowing both Israelis and Palestinians to determine their own futures and destinies, advocating for a peaceful resolution to the conflict in the region.
Shapiro’s self-identification as a “past volunteer in the Israeli army” was clarified by his spokesman, who explained that the service project took place in high school and involved volunteering on an Israeli army base but did not include any military activities. During a press conference, Shapiro addressed the controversy surrounding the old op-ed, acknowledging his age at the time of writing and highlighting the time that has passed since then. He reiterated his support for a two-state solution and his criticism of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whom he has described as one of the worst leaders of all time. Despite facing backlash for his past remarks, Shapiro remains committed to promoting unity, listening to diverse perspectives, and advocating for peace in the Middle East.
As Shapiro continues to navigate potential criticisms and scrutiny over his past views on Israel and the Palestinian people, his commitment to evolving his beliefs and engaging with diverse communities remains central to his approach as governor of Pennsylvania. His interactions with various religious and ethnic groups within the state have played a significant role in shaping his current perspective on the Middle East conflict. By emphasizing the importance of cooperation, dialogue, and mutual understanding, Shapiro aims to bridge divides, promote inclusivity, and work towards a peaceful resolution for Israelis and Palestinians in the region. Despite the challenges and controversies he faces, Shapiro remains dedicated to building a more united and harmonious Pennsylvania for all its residents.
