Despite popular belief and media coverage, residential evictions in New York City are not surging as many have claimed. The false argument that evictions are on the rise was often used to support the idea of “good-cause eviction” laws, which would have made it very difficult to evict non-paying tenants. However, the state Legislature passed a watered-down version of these laws, leading to complaints that it did not go far enough. The New York Times and other news outlets frequently portrayed a picture of renters being thrown onto the street wholesale, but the reality is quite different.
In reality, evictions did rise in most of 2022 and 2023, but this was largely due to a backlog of cases from a statewide eviction moratorium in effect until mid-January 2022. When compared to the years prior to 2020, the number of evictions in 2023 actually decreased. For example, the 12,139 apartment tenant evictions in 2023 were 28.6% fewer than in 2019. Additionally, total evictions in 2023 were barely half of the previous 20-year average, excluding the moratorium period. This is a stark contrast to 2015 when there were more than 25,000 evictions in a single year.
These statistics come from a reliable source, the New York City Rent Guideline’s Board, rather than a real estate lobbying organization. The Board’s 2024 Income and Affordability Study provides a clear picture of the eviction rates in the city, showing a significant decrease in evictions compared to previous years. These numbers, outlined in the report, offer a more accurate portrayal of the situation and dispel the myth that evictions are surging across New York City.
The misinformation surrounding eviction rates has led to misconceptions about the state of housing in the city. Many have called for stricter eviction laws to protect renters, citing the false narrative of surging evictions. The reality, as evidenced by the data from the Rent Guideline’s Board, tells a different story. By understanding the actual eviction rates and trends in New York City, policymakers and activists can make more informed decisions about housing policy and support systems for residents in need.
The narrative of surging evictions in New York City has been perpetuated by biased media coverage, leading to misconceptions about the state of housing in the city. This false information has influenced public opinion and policy decisions, creating a sense of urgency around the need for stricter eviction laws. However, the data from the Rent Guideline’s Board tells a different story, revealing a decrease in evictions compared to previous years. By dispelling these myths and focusing on accurate information, stakeholders can work towards effective solutions to address housing challenges in the city.
Moving forward, it is essential to rely on data-driven insights and accurate information to inform policy decisions and public discourse around housing issues in New York City. By understanding the true eviction rates and trends in the city, stakeholders can develop targeted interventions that address the root causes of housing insecurity and support vulnerable residents. This shift towards evidence-based policymaking will help create a more equitable and sustainable housing landscape in the city, benefiting both tenants and landlords alike.
