Horse trainer Jonathan Creswell, 36, was found dead in Londonderry one day after the trial into the death of Katie Simpson, 21, began. He was accused of having raped and murdered her. Creswell was found dead in a chilling turn of events during his own trial. His death was not considered suspicious.
Londonderry Crown Court heard that Creswell had a sexual relationship with Katie, despite sharing two children with her sister Christina. He became angry when he discovered Katie was in a relationship with someone else. The jury was informed that Creswell had raped and strangled Katie and attempted to make her death look like a suicide. Katie passed away in hospital on August 9, 2020. Creswell posted a tribute to Katie on Facebook on the day of her death. His post expressed admiration for Katie and described her as a hard worker and a beloved aunt to his children.
Katie Simpson’s mother, Noleen, described her daughter as being passionate about horses, friends, family, and socializing. She was known for her kind and outgoing nature and her ability to connect with people of all ages. Creswell allegedly murdered Katie a week after an incident in their shared home where he reportedly raped her. The prosecution argued that Creswell lied about finding Katie hanging in the stairwell and told medical staff she had taken her own life. A witness reported hearing a scream, but prosecutors claimed it was Creswell pretending to be shocked. Katie’s injuries indicated she had been struck with a rod-type implement.
Creswell’s behavior raised suspicions as he pretended to be the one who discovered Katie’s body and attempted to pass her death off as a suicide. The trial brought to light the alleged violent nature of Katie’s final moments and the brutal attack she suffered. The case shocked the community and Katie’s loved ones, who remembered her as a vibrant and caring individual. Creswell’s tragic death during the trial added a new layer of mystery and tragedy to the already heartbreaking story. The trial into Katie’s death shed light on a devastating crime that left many searching for answers and justice for the young showjumper.
