Former LA County Sheriff Jim McDonnell has been chosen to lead the Los Angeles Police Department by Mayor Karen Bass, with the goal of reducing crime and enhancing public safety. McDonnell’s background includes serving as LA County Sheriff, LAPD officer for 29 years, and Long Beach police chief for almost five years. His priorities include growing the force, ensuring constitutional policing, and preparing for upcoming major events like the 2026 World Cup, 2027 Super Bowl, and 2028 Olympics.
Chief Michel Moore retired in early 2024, leading to Dominic Choi serving as interim chief. Bass’s decision to appoint McDonnell as the new chief ends the debate over selecting an “insider” or “outsider” to bring change to the department’s culture. McDonnell, a white male, beat out other finalists, Deputy Chief Emada Tingirides, a Black woman, and former Assistant Chief Robert “Bobby” Arcos, who is Latino. Despite hopes for a Latino or female chief, Bass emphasized her commitment to diversity and inclusion within the LAPD.
McDonnell’s appointment comes at a time when the LAPD faces criticism over its response to protests and high-profile shootings by officers. The department struggles with recruitment, excessive use of force, and low morale among officers. A report released by Bass highlighting concerns raised by officers and community groups emphasized the need for transparency, de-escalation, and fair disciplinary processes within the department. Fernando Rejón of the Urban Peace Institute hopes that McDonnell will focus on nonpunitive approaches to community safety.
Critics like Janel Belovette Jenkins of the Los Angeles Black Worker Center believe that hiring a new chief does not address the root issues of overpolicing and the allocation of resources away from housing and jobs. However, the Los Angeles Police Protective League, the union representing officers, expressed support for Bass’s choice, believing it reflects a commitment to improve officer staffing and morale. McDonnell’s experience as both an insider and outsider within law enforcement, along with his background in implementing reforms, makes him a strategic choice for the position.
John Sullivan, a retired lieutenant, described McDonnell as a “hybrid” insider-outsider due to his experience within the LAPD, Long Beach PD, and as LA County Sheriff. McDonnell’s track record in implementing reforms following scandals and his work with public safety research institutions provide a strong foundation for his role as police chief. With major events on the horizon, like the 2028 Olympics and potential security threats, McDonnell’s expertise in risk analysis and counterterrorism could prove invaluable in ensuring the safety of Los Angeles residents. Overall, his appointment signals a new chapter for the LAPD as it navigates challenges and strives for accountability and community trust.
