Asian American TikTok users have been discussing a question raised on a recent podcast about whether “SoCal Asians” have a superiority complex. Southern California is seen as a mecca for Asian American culture, with a high population percentage in areas like Los Angeles and Orange County. This perspective has led to discomfort and unnecessary dynamics for Asians outside of the region, who feel pressure to prove they are also part of that culture. The debate over this superiority complex started with a clip from The 949 Podcast, where one host mentioned feeling superior to Asians from other states because they are not from California. This comment sparked backlash on TikTok, with many sharing negative experiences of being judged by SoCal Asians for not being “Asian enough” if they grew up in predominantly white spaces.
Many Asian Americans outside of California expressed frustrations with the dismissive and judgmental behavior they have experienced from SoCal Asians. They have been questioned about their connections to their heritage, the type of food they eat, and their cultural interests, all as a way to determine if they are “whitewashed” or not. Jennifer Kang, who moved from California to Oregon, shared her experience of being labeled as “more whitewashed” by a friend from California after she moved. She emphasized that there is no set measure for being Asian and that it is wrong to judge someone based on their access to Asian culture or interests.
James Zarsadiaz, a history professor at the University of San Francisco, explained that regional stereotypes contribute to the perception of a superiority complex among SoCal Asians. The idea of coastal regions being trendier and more sophisticated than the interior of the country leads to misconceptions about the lack of access to Asian American culture in states between the coasts. Zarsadiaz emphasized the importance of embracing regional differences in Asian American experiences and understanding the unique challenges and struggles faced by different communities.
The criticism of SoCal Asians from those outside the region stems from the trauma of being marginalized in their own communities. Zarsadiaz noted that this double rejection – from both non-Asians and other Asians – can be painful and isolating. Jennifer Kang highlighted the pressure felt by Asian Americans in predominantly white areas to assimilate and fit in with their white peers, leading to the hiding of cultural aspects and feeling like they don’t belong in either group. She emphasized the importance of inclusivity and bringing people into the Asian American community rather than keeping them out.
In conclusion, it is essential for Asian Americans to recognize and address issues of superiority complexes and gatekeeping within the community. Instead of judging and excluding others based on their cultural backgrounds or interests, there should be a focus on inclusivity and sharing the rich history and heritage of Asian culture. Embracing regional differences and understanding the unique challenges faced by different Asian American communities can help foster unity and solidarity within the group. Ultimately, the goal should be to create a welcoming and supportive environment for all Asian Americans, regardless of where they are from or how closely they align with certain cultural norms.
