The NFL will be enforcing a new rule next season to ban the “hip-drop tackle” in an effort to improve player safety. This rule has sparked controversy among players, both current and former, who believe it will hinder defenders’ ability to tackle opponents effectively. The tackle involves a defender wrapping the ball carrier with his hands or arms and dropping his hips, which can trap the ball carrier’s legs and feet. San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle, known for being hard to take down on the field, shared his concerns about the rule, which will result in a 15-yard penalty when enforced. While Kittle believes the tackle doesn’t often cause injuries, he worries that unnecessary penalties could disrupt the flow of the game.
According to NFL executive Jeff Miller, hip-drop tackles occurred 230 times last season, resulting in 15 players missing game time due to injuries. Kittle acknowledges the challenges of finding alternative tackling techniques, especially when a defender needs to make a quick decision while a player is running away from them. He recognizes the league’s efforts to prioritize player safety but highlights the importance of having a healthy conversation about when to enforce the new rule to avoid causing a penalty-filled game. Detroit Lions wide receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown also acknowledges the risks associated with the hip-drop tackle and supports the league’s decision to implement this rule change.
Despite being an offensive player who stands to benefit from the new rule, Kittle empathizes with defenders who may find it challenging to adjust their tackling techniques. He acknowledges the potential impact on defenders who may unintentionally execute a hip-drop tackle and suffer consequences as a result. Kittle hopes that the NFL will strike a balance in enforcing the rule to ensure player safety without significantly altering the fundamental aspects of the game. St. Brown expresses understanding of the league’s efforts to protect players, acknowledging the difficulty defenders may face in adapting their tackling methods while also recognizing the importance of prioritizing player safety.
The NFL has faced criticism for rule changes in the past, such as restrictions on leading with the helmet or avoiding putting full body weight on quarterbacks during tackles. However, players, coaches, and fans have adapted to these changes in the interest of preserving player safety. Kittle remains optimistic that the enforcement of the new rule banning the hip-drop tackle will not alter the game drastically and emphasizes the need for consistency in applying the rule to maintain the integrity of the sport. St. Brown echoes Kittle’s sentiments, expressing gratitude for the league’s efforts to protect players, even if it means defenders must adjust their playing style. Both players emphasize the importance of striking a balance between player safety and the essence of the game as they look ahead to the upcoming NFL season.
