The book “The Line: AI and the Future of Personhood” by Duke University law professor James Boyle explores the potential scenario in which AI agents achieve personhood alongside humans. Boyle’s interest in this topic dates back over a decade, and he believes that intelligent machines will eventually attain some form of personhood. He discusses how AI has advanced significantly since 2011, with sophisticated chatbots and other AI technologies becoming more human-like. Boyle initially thought AI would have to be granted personhood on moral grounds due to their human-like qualities, but now believes legal personality for AI may be achieved out of convenience, much like it was for corporations.
Boyle discusses whether AI agents will ever become conscious, with neuroscientist Christof Koch believing that current computer architectures cannot support human-level consciousness. Boyle argues that while the current architecture may not allow for consciousness in AI agents, future advancements may make this possible. He believes that AI creations will face a new kind of test in the future as humans grapple with how to treat these intelligent machines. Boyle explores the ethical, legal, and societal consequences that will arise as AI evolves and potentially crosses the line that marks the boundary of personhood.
Boyle draws inspiration from science fiction, specifically the movie “Blade Runner” and the novel “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep,” to frame his views on how AI agents might be treated in the future. He discusses the Voight-Kampff test used in the movie to determine whether an entity is a replicant or a human based on their level of empathy. Boyle predicts that in the future, companies may market AI agents as self-actualizing entities deserving of fair treatment, akin to fair-trade products, while others may market them as commoditized servants. He anticipates a division in the market based on how AI creations are perceived and treated.
The book “The Line: AI and the Future of Personhood” is available in print and online for free, reflecting Boyle’s advocacy for open access to information. Christof Koch, a renowned neuroscientist, has also written books on consciousness and AI. Boyle emphasizes the unpredictable timeline for when AI may achieve personhood and stresses the importance of treating AI creations with consideration in the meantime. The impact of AI advancements on society, ethics, and law is a topic of ongoing discussion, with questions remaining about the implications of intelligent machines crossing the threshold into personhood. As the field of AI evolves, so too will the discussions surrounding the rights and responsibilities accorded to AI agents.
