The article delves into the issue of class bias in the media and political narratives, using a recent interview with Republican Vice-Presidential candidate JD Vance as an example. During the interview, ABC’s Martha Raddatz downplayed concerns about Venezuelan gangs infiltrating Aurora, Colorado, dismissing the issue as affecting only a few apartment complexes. This dismissal, while seemingly benign, reflects a broader trend of media elites minimizing vital issues facing poorer communities. The divide between different factions within the two parties is also highlighted, with lawmakers from poorer districts increasingly challenging traditional power structures in Congress.
The research paper “Class Dismissed” explores the socioeconomic makeup of major congressional caucuses, revealing that members representing the poorest districts tend to challenge party leadership and advocate for their constituents. The caucus with the lowest average median incomes includes both conservative and liberal lawmakers, demonstrating that class bias transcends partisan lines. In contrast, members representing wealthier communities are often viewed as more responsible legislators. This class bias stems from narrative-makers being disconnected from the experiences of lawmakers representing poorer Americans, leading to a lack of understanding and representation in the media.
In a post-COVID world where disparities between white collar workers and poor communities have widened, constituents from distressed areas are looking to their representatives to fight for their interests. The neglect of these experiences by mainstream media has led to political implications, including shifts in voter demographics. Recent polls show Donald Trump gaining support from Black and Hispanic voters, as well as working-class white voters, while national Democrats are appealing to educated and wealthier Americans. This realignment suggests the GOP is becoming the party of the diverse working class, while Democrats cater to a more affluent base.
The column draws parallels between the narrative of “The Wizard of Oz” and the musical “Wicked” to depict the current political landscape. Just as the wicked Witch of the West faced challenges fitting into the social structure, there are underlying dynamics in today’s electorate that influence political judgments. The authors, Sam Geduldig and Ja’Ron Smith, suggest that understanding these dynamics is crucial for shaping future political discourse and policies. They argue that realignment in American politics is possible through presidential elections, as they offer a more blended electorate compared to Congress, which may help challenge existing class bias in media and political narratives. Smith is the author of “Underserved: Harnessing the Principles of Lincoln’s Vision for Reconstruction for Today’s Forgotten Communities,” bringing a historical perspective to contemporary issues.
