Two Georgia district attorneys, Shalena Cook Jones and Deborah Gonzalez, who promised criminal justice reforms are facing reelection races amidst criticism from state Republicans and some local Democrats. Cook Jones and Gonzalez, elected in 2020 after nationwide protests against racial injustice, advocate for a holistic approach to prosecuting that includes diversion programs and rehabilitation for nonviolent offenders. Their opponents argue that they have been ineffective in prosecuting violent crimes and have led dysfunctional offices.
In response to the rise of progressive prosecutors, Republicans in various states, including Georgia, have attempted to remove what they call “woke prosecutors.” In 2020, Cook Jones defeated her former boss, a tough-on-crime Republican incumbent in Chatham County, while Gonzalez took office in a circuit that includes liberal and conservative areas. Both district attorneys have faced backlash for their policies on prosecution, sentencing, and rehabilitation programs, with Gonzalez retracted a memorandum detailing these policies due to intense criticism.
Gonzalez describes herself as an outspoken Democrat and progressive prosecutor, facing criticism for her approach to justice. In 2023, Georgia Governor Brian Kemp signed a law creating a commission to discipline prosecutors deemed “far-left.” Cook Jones and Gonzalez argue that the backlash against them is part of a smear campaign and overlooks mistakes made by other district attorneys. Gonzalez’s office has faced legal reprimands but also boasts accomplishments such as expunging records and resentencing individuals.
After taking office, both Cook Jones and Gonzalez experienced significant staff turnover, with many leaving due to policy disagreements and poor management. Critics argue that the district attorneys lack prosecutorial experience and have not effectively handled their offices, leading to dysfunction. Cook Jones has restaffed her office, but faces criticism for dismissing murder cases involving indicted police officers. She emphasizes the need for a balanced approach to law enforcement and accountability for public officials who break laws.
Both Cook Jones and Gonzalez have faced legal challenges and criticism in their roles as district attorneys. Cook Jones has been reprimanded for unethical behavior and faced an ethics complaint, while Gonzalez has been cited for various violations. Despite these challenges, both district attorneys have made efforts to clear case backlogs and implement reforms in their offices. Cook Jones hopes voters will focus on her work expanding diversion programs and holding officials accountable, while Gonzalez highlights accomplishments like expunging records and referring juveniles to restorative justice programs.
As the reelection races unfold, Cook Jones and Gonzalez are facing scrutiny from opponents who argue they are not fit for their roles as district attorneys. While facing criticism for their policies and management of their offices, both district attorneys continue to advocate for reform and a more progressive approach to criminal justice. Their ability to survive reelection in the face of intense blowback will test the resilience of progressive prosecutors in Georgia’s political landscape.
