City Council leaders recently questioned the NYPD over concerning social media posts by top officials and unexpected overtime costs related to handling protests and migrant shelters. The probe was initiated by the Department of Investigation at the request of Council Speaker Adrienne Adams and the Legal Aid Society due to concerns that the posts may convey inaccurate or misleading information and incite threats of violence. Adams emphasized that such conduct is dangerous, unethical, and unprofessional, especially given the department’s mission to preserve peace, protect the people, and reduce fear.
The posts in question included a controversial jab by NYPD Chief of Patrol John Chell at Queens Councilwoman Tiffany Caban, which was later deleted. The exchange between Chell and Caban raised concerns about potential threats and the impact on democracy. The NYPD has over 250 social media accounts, which department higher-ups have control of, with the intention to inform the public rather than inflame tensions with elected officials. Department brass have used social media to push back against perceived anti-cop policies, including initiatives like the “How Many Stops” program.
Council Speaker Adams expressed her concerns during the budget hearing, questioning NYPD Deputy Commissioner Michael Gerber about Chell’s response to Caban. Gerber reiterated the importance of allowing the DOI probe to proceed and stated that the department was fully cooperating with the investigation. Adams continued to press the issue, questioning the appropriateness of the post and seeking clarification on potential disciplinary actions. The meeting highlighted an ongoing tension between the council and the NYPD over social media usage and responses to criticism.
In addition to the social media posts, City Council leaders also addressed the issue of NYPD overtime costs, which amounted to approximately $788 million during the 2024 fiscal year as of March – surpassing the budget by almost $271 million. Commissioner Edward Caban attributed the majority of the additional overtime spending to security measures at migrant shelters, enhanced translation services, and deployment related to protests. He emphasized that the events leading to the increased spending were unprecedented and unforeseen, requiring resources beyond what was initially budgeted.
The discussions at the budget hearing shed light on the challenges faced by the NYPD in managing both social media communications and unexpected financial burdens. The inquiry into the social media posts by department officials highlights the need for accountability and appropriate conduct, especially in a role that involves maintaining public safety and trust. The significant amount of overtime spending, while attributed to unique circumstances, raises questions about agency management and budget planning. Moving forward, there will likely be continued scrutiny and calls for transparency from both the City Council and the NYPD in addressing these critical issues.
