Extra-firm mattresses are ideal for those who prefer a more supportive feel while sleeping, especially for back or stomach sleepers and plus-size individuals. These mattresses help align the spine healthily and reduce back pain. CNET’s team of sleep experts has tested over 200 mattresses and compiled a list of the best extra-firm options available. The Plank mattress by Brooklyn Bedding, with its dual firmness levels and affordable price, is recommended as the best overall extra-firm mattress. The Plank Firm Natural Mattress offers 30% off sitewide with a code and is a latex foam hybrid with a 120-night trial and 10-year limited warranty.
The Avocado Green mattress, a certified organic latex hybrid, is another top pick for its eco-friendly materials and firmness level. Endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association, this mattress is suitable for strict back and stomach sleepers. The Saatva Classic is also highly recommended for back pain relief, featuring multiple coil layers and zoned support. The Helix Luxe Twilight model, with a luxurious hybrid design and firmness level, offers a balance of pressure relief and support. The Titan Plus Luxe mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is designed for heavy sleepers with its durable construction and support. Allswell Brick, an affordable hybrid mattress, is a budget-friendly option for those seeking an extra-firm feel.
While these are the top extra-firm mattresses, other options like the Amerisleep AS2 Hybrid and WinkBed mattress are worth considering for their balance of relief and support. Factors to consider when shopping for an extra-firm mattress include sleeping position, body type, and budget. Extra-firm mattresses are recommended for back and stomach sleepers, while side sleepers should be cautious as it may cause pressure points. Body type influences how firm a mattress feels, with heavier individuals sinking more into the bed. Budget is an important consideration, as mattresses can range from $300 to over $2,000. The construction of a mattress, such as memory foam layers or coil systems, determines its firmness level.
