Angel Hernandez’s career as an MLB umpire has been marked by controversy and criticism. One of his most infamous moments came in a game in 2013 when he made a crucial missed call on a home run that impacted the outcome of the game. This incident, along with other questionable decisions and confrontations with players and coaches, has solidified Hernandez’s reputation as one of the most polarizing figures in the sport. Despite this negative perception, those close to Hernandez describe him as a caring and genuine individual who is passionate about his job and wishes the criticism would dissipate.
Hernandez’s journey to the major leagues began at a young age when he started umpiring Little League games at the urging of his father. He worked his way up through the ranks, facing challenges and adversity along the way. Despite his success in reaching the big leagues, Hernandez has been met with criticism and scrutiny throughout his career. His on-field decisions, particularly his strike zone, have come under intense scrutiny, with many fans and players questioning his abilities as an umpire.
Statistically, Hernandez ranks in the middle of the pack among MLB umpires, according to Umpire Auditor data. Despite this, he continues to attract attention for his questionable calls and interactions with players and coaches. Hernandez’s defenders argue that he is unfairly singled out and that his mistakes are magnified due to the increased visibility of umpires in today’s game. They point to his passion for the job and his desire to get calls right as evidence of his commitment to the game.
In 2017, Hernandez filed a lawsuit against MLB, alleging racial discrimination and claiming that he was passed over for promotions because of his race. The lawsuit was ultimately dismissed, with the league citing concerns about Hernandez’s conduct on the field and his interactions with other umpires as reasons for their decisions. Despite the legal challenges and criticism he has faced, Hernandez remains employed as an MLB umpire, with little recourse for the league to make changes in the absence of a direct violation.
While Hernandez’s on-field performance has been the subject of much debate, those who know him personally defend his character and integrity. They describe him as a kind and caring individual who is dedicated to his family and friends. Despite the ongoing criticism and negative attention, Hernandez’s supporters believe that he deserves more credit for his contributions to the game and the positive impact he has had on those around him.
In the end, the controversy surrounding Angel Hernandez highlights the complexities of officiating in professional sports. Umpires, like players, are subject to scrutiny and criticism, but they also play a crucial role in ensuring the integrity and fairness of the game. While Hernandez may never escape the shadow of his reputation, those who know him best continue to stand by him, offering a more nuanced perspective on a figure who has become a lightning rod for controversy in Major League Baseball.
